We’ve all heard of sartorial manrepellers, but do we actually care? Not The Handbook’s Contributing Fashion & Lifestyle Editor, Astrid Carter. Dressing entirely for herself has never been something she shies away from. And even when her sometimes off-beat fashion choices leave her other half perplexed, it only adds to the fun and the theatre of getting dressed. Here, she talks through the clothes her boyfriend hates (that she utterly adores).

Despite how this piece may read, I don’t actively go out of my way to wear things my other half thinks are insane. I just love clothes that bring me joy, and I never really think about what others might think. My boyfriend loves to comment on some of my fruitier choices – a striped trouser or a dramatically ruffled high-neck blouse – but it’s all in jest. I think he secretly loves the fact that I get such a kick out of what I wear (it’s part of my job, after all), but it certainly provides us with endless banter before leaving the house. Here are some of the pieces I love… and he finds hilarious…

I just love clothes that bring me joy, and I never really think about what others might think.

Astrid, Contributing Fashion & Lifestyle Editor

1. Loafers

I’ll caveat this by saying it’s probably not all loafers, but a select few in my collection are utter man-repellers. First up: a pair of excellent vintage M&S chunky loafers – a £5 charity shop score from years ago and arguably one of my best buys to date. With a gloriously chunky sole and a carmel/white/brown colour palette, I wear them at least once a week because they go with literally everything, from mini hemlines and socks to my everyday jeans and tailored trousers.

Fun fact: I actually wore them on our second date, when he humorously referred to them as “1950s golf shoes.” I wasn’t remotely bothered then, and I’m still wearing them years later. Other notable offenders in the collection include leopard print and stark white, both of which are guaranteed to inspire a little comment whenever they leave the house.

Other notable offenders include leopard print & stark white, both of which are guaranteed to inspire a little comment whenever they leave the house.

SHOP SIMILAR…

2. Vinyl jackets

A woman with wavy hair stands in a room with large windows overlooking a lake. She wears a long, multi-textured coat featuring brown snakeskin and light blue panels—one of those signature pieces of “clothes my boyfriend hates.” She stands on a decorative rug between two small tables with green banquettes.

I own two rather fabulous Kitri vinyl jackets (RIP to the brand, which sadly closed this summer – though I did manage to nab my second one in their clearance sale for an absolute steal). The first is a patchwork delight of powder blue, caramel, and snakeskin that garners endless compliments from the gals and the gays. The BF, however, is significantly less impressed, regularly likening it to Joseph and his Amazing Technicolour Dreamcoat.

The second is a jet-black vinyl situation featuring detachable (and wonderfully obnoxious) white Mongolian fur collar and cuffs. On her maiden voyage, he asked if I was heading to a Berlin sex club. As fashion insults go, I’ve had far worse. Water off a duck’s back. Or, indeed, a very practical collection of waterproof vinyl jackets.

On her maiden voyage, he asked if I was heading to a Berlin sex club. As fashion insults go, I’ve had far worse.

SHOP SIMILAR..

3. Striped trousers

A woman stands on a sunny forest path with mountains in the background, confidently wearing the striped trousers and light shirt from the collection of clothes my boyfriend hates, along with red shoes and sunglasses. She is holding a bag, surrounded by tall trees and blue sky.

Anyone who knows me knows I go absolutely feral for striped trousers. My partner, however, calls them “the clown trousers,” usually followed by questions about when I’m due back at the circus. But whether it’s laid-back pyjama styles in the summer or ’70s-inspired flared numbers, they remain a beloved staple and feel so inherently me in my version of a “capsule wardrobe” – and they aren’t going anywhere.

They remain a beloved staple & feel so inherently me that they aren’t going anywhere.

And despite his upfront rinsing, he did – rather sweetly – follow me around Liberty recently on a mission to hunt down a pair of La Veste’s iconic striped pants. I hasten to add, they were out of stock, but his temporary support of a jazzy trouser was noted and much appreciated.

SHOP SIMILAR…

4. Midi skirts

A woman with wavy hair takes a mirror selfie in a cosy, floral-wallpapered room. Showcasing her unique fashion sense, she wears a patterned jumper and striped skirt, holding a phone with a red chequered case and beaded strap.

I’ll spare you the exact comment he made about a Damson Madder plaid midi skirt for fear of him getting cancelled online, but safe to say, he was not a fan. I don’t think men always get the whole voluminous, oversized silhouette thing, and that’s fine – Lord knows we’re not dressing for them anymore.

The same applied to a vintage kilt-esque skirt I packed for a trip to the Highlands recently (granted, perhaps a little too on the nose), where it was met with a look of sheer bewilderment.

I don’t think men always get the whole voluminous, oversized silhouette thing, and that’s fine – Lord knows we’re not dressing for them anymore.

SHOP SIMILAR…

5. High-neck blouses

A woman with long brown hair takes a mirror selfie in a stylish room, showing off her fashion sense in a white blouse and light trousers. The background features green curtains, a blue chair, a marble table, and wall art.

I think the art of the grown-up going-out top is often lost on straight men in their 40s. My idea of a chic evening top – the kind that is the entire outfit – isn’t sequined, tight, or strappy. Instead, it’s fluid and elegant. Liquid silk draped across the body, perhaps an exaggerated shoulder, definitely a dramatic high neckline, and as much excess fabric as humanly possible.

To my boyfriend, this translates as Queen Elizabeth I, a Shakespearean court jester, or a barrister heading to the Old Bailey. 

I think the art of the grown-up going-out top is often lost on straight men in their 40s.

Off-white, blush pink, and classic black are my go-tos (H&M consistently drops great high-street options every season, while Toteme and Rohe are top of the wish list), but I’m currently itching to get my hands on NA-KD’s dramatic caped iteration in creamy buttermilk. Divine paired with tailored chocolate-brown trousers and my aforementioned and utterly beloved chunky loafers for an autumn date-night look. One which I’m sure will send him completely sideways.

SHOP SIMILAR…

The products on this page have been selected by our editorial team, however, The Handbook may make a small commission on some products purchased through affiliate links.


Want to receive more great articles like this every day? Join our daily email now